Thinking about visiting Key West? Stopping by Key West Key Lime Pie Co is an absolute must!

Our American Pie Council award winning pies are always made with fresh and all natural ingredients. USA Today’s “10 Best”named us the best pie in Florida and you may have seen us on popular television shows like Food Network's Throw Down With Bobby Flay and CNBC’s The Profit with Marcus Lemonis. We stand by our motto, If we don't make it, we don't sell it!

Our traditional key lime pies are a popular favorite, but we also offer a variety of the classic flavors with a twist - you’ve got to try our mango, blueberry, toasted coconut, and extra tart flavors. We can even dip your slice in rich and decadent chocolate. It’s the perfect frozen treat on a stick to savor in paradise! Gluten free crust options are also available for persons with allergies.

CLASS OFFERINGS: We are excited to announce a one of a kind experience at our store! Want to know how to make the most popular dessert on the island? Go behind the scenes and learn to make your own mini key lime pie. Get more information about our classes or sign up online here.

You can also find us at more than 60 locations from Key Largo to Key West and all around the U.S. 

Key West Key Lime Pie Company is located at

511 Greene Street,
Key West FL 33040
Phone: (305) 517-6720

Hours: 9:30am - 9:30pm Monday thru Sunday
Call for hours on Thanksgiving and Christmas