Mini Key Lime Pie

Our best in-store contender has made its way to our website. We now ship our mini pies to you at home.

The same amazing recipe as our 100-year-old traditional pie recipe. A 5-inch mini pie is more than just a slice and is the perfect amount of pie. Our mini pies have a fridge life of one week or 6 months in the freezer.

Our traditional key lime pies are a popular favorite, but we also offer a variety of classic flavors with a twist—you've got to try our pineapple coconut, strawberry, mango, and extra tart flavors.

We do not ship on the week of major holidays! December18th, before 1pm Eastern time, is your last day to ship before Christmas. 

Our pies are good in the freezer for 6 months. Always serve it frozen, like an ice cream cake. Serve it 10 to 15 minutes out of the freezer. So place your order today before it's too late!

We ship using a two-day or next-day shipping service only on Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday. Orders placed before 1 pm Eastern time will be shipped that day; if later, the order will ship the following shipping day. If we receive Next Day orders before 1 pm Eastern time on Thursday, they will be shipped for Friday delivery.

No Saturday deliveries or weekend travel time.